Easy2Siksha.com
GNDU QUESTION PAPERS 2024
B.com 4
th
SEMESTER
INDUSTRIAL LAWS
Time Allowed: 3 Hours Maximum Marks: 50
Note: Aempt Five quesons in all, selecng at least One queson from each secon. The
Fih queson may be aempted from any secon. All quesons carry equal marks.
SECTION-A
1. State the provisions of Factories Act 1948 with regard to safety of workers.
2. Describe briey how trade unions are registered and cercate of registraon thereof
issued under the Trade Unions Act, 1926?
SECTION-B
3. What authories have been set up under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 for
invesgaon and selement of industrial disputes?
4. Enumerate the provision of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 relang to strikes and lock-
out.
SECTION-C
5. What are the dues of Employees' State Insurance Corporaon and Standing Commiee
?
Easy2Siksha.com
6. What are the dierent types of benets provided by the Employees State Insurance Act,
1948?
SECTION-D
7. Explain when an employer is liable to pay compensaon to an employee injured by
accident 'arising out of and in the course of employment'?
8. State the rules regarding distribuon of compensaon under the Workmen's
Compensaon Act, 1923?
GNDU ANSWER PAPERS 2024
B.com 4
th
SEMESTER
INDUSTRIAL LAWS
Time Allowed: 3 Hours Maximum Marks: 50
Note: Aempt Five quesons in all, selecng at least One queson from each secon. The
Fih queson may be aempted from any secon. All quesons carry equal marks.
SECTION-A
1. State the provisions of Factories Act 1948 with regard to safety of workers.
Ans: The Factories Act, 1948 is one of the most important laws in India that protects
workers in factories. Think of it like a safety shield for workers—its main goal is to ensure
that people working in factories are safe, healthy, and treated properly.
Why Safety Provisions Are Important
Easy2Siksha.com
Imagine working in a factory with big machines, loud noises, heat, and chemicals. Without
proper rules, even a small mistake could cause serious injury. The Factories Act ensures
that:
• Workers don’t get hurt
• Machines are safe to use
• Emergencies can be handled properly
It’s like having a protective system in place before danger happens.
1. Fencing of Machinery
One of the most basic safety rules is covering dangerous machine parts.
All moving parts like belts, gears, and cutting blades must be properly fenced (covered).
Why?
Because these parts can easily trap clothes, hands, or hair.
Simple idea:
If a machine can harm you, it must be covered.
2. Work on or Near Machinery in Motion
Sometimes machines cannot be stopped for repairs. In such cases:
• Only trained adults are allowed to work
• They must wear tight-fitting clothes
• Special precautions must be taken
This prevents accidents caused by loose clothing or lack of knowledge.
3. Employment of Young Persons on Dangerous Machines
Young workers (especially below 18 years):
• Cannot work on dangerous machines
• Must receive proper training and supervision
This ensures that inexperienced workers are not exposed to high risks.
Easy2Siksha.com
4. Striking Gear and Emergency Controls
Every machine should have:
• A switch to stop it immediately
• Emergency controls that are easy to reach
In case something goes wrong, workers can quickly stop the machine.
5. Precautions Against Fire
Factories must have proper fire safety arrangements:
• Fire extinguishers
• Emergency exits
• Alarm systems
Workers should also be trained in fire safety.
Simple Fire Safety Diagram
[Machine Area] [Exit Door]
| |
Fire ---> Workers move →→→
|
Fire Extinguisher
This shows how workers should move towards exits during a fire.
6. Precautions Against Dangerous Fumes and Gases
Factories dealing with chemicals must:
• Provide proper ventilation
• Test air quality
• Provide safety equipment like masks
Workers should not enter confined spaces unless it is safe.
Easy2Siksha.com
7. Safety of Floors, Stairs, and Access
• Floors must not be slippery
• Stairs should have railings
• Safe pathways should be provided
This prevents falls and injuries.
8. Protection Against Dangerous Electrical Hazards
Factories must:
• Properly insulate wires
• Avoid exposed electrical systems
• Regularly check equipment
Electricity is invisible but dangerous, so prevention is key.
9. Maintenance of Buildings
Factory buildings must be:
• Strong and well-maintained
• Free from cracks or damage
Unsafe buildings can collapse or cause accidents.
10. Handling of Hazardous Substances
If a factory uses chemicals:
• Proper storage is required
• Workers must be informed about risks
• Safety training must be given
Knowledge is the best protection.
11. Safety Officers
Easy2Siksha.com
In large factories:
• Safety officers are appointed
• They monitor risks and enforce rules
Think of them as “guardians of safety”.
12. Machine Maintenance and Inspection
• Machines must be regularly checked
• Faulty machines should not be used
Prevention is better than repair after accidents.
13. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
Workers must be provided with:
• Helmets
• Gloves
• Goggles
• Safety shoes
PPE acts like a personal shield.
PPE Concept Diagram
Worker
/ | \
Helmet Gloves Shoes
➡ Protects head, hands, and feet
Conclusion
The Factories Act, 1948 is not just a law—it is a lifesaving system. It ensures that:
• Machines are safe
• Workers are trained
Easy2Siksha.com
• Emergencies are controlled
• Hazards are minimized
In simple words:
“A safe factory is a productive factory.”
These provisions create a work environment where workers can focus on their jobs without
fear. When safety is taken seriously, accidents reduce, efficiency improves, and everyone
benefits—workers, employers, and society.
2. Describe briey how trade unions are registered and cercate of registraon thereof
issued under the Trade Unions Act, 1926?
Ans: First, What is a Trade Union?
A trade union is simply an organized group of workers who come together to protect their
rights, improve working conditions, and negotiate with employers. For example, factory
workers may form a union to demand fair wages or safer workplaces.
But for a union to be legally recognized, it must be registered under the Trade Unions Act,
1926. Registration gives the union legal status and certain rights.
Process of Registration under the Trade Unions Act, 1926
1. Application for Registration
• Workers who want to form a union must apply to the Registrar of Trade Unions (an
official appointed by the government).
• The application must include:
o The name of the trade union.
o The address of its head office.
o Names, occupations, and addresses of its office-bearers.
o A copy of the union’s rules (constitution).
At least seven members of the union must sign the application.
2. Requirements for Registration
The union must meet certain conditions:
• The rules should clearly state the union’s objectives, membership criteria,
subscription fees, and how funds will be used.
• The rules must also explain how office-bearers are elected and how disputes are
settled.
Easy2Siksha.com
• The union must not have a name that is too similar to an existing registered union
(to avoid confusion).
3. Role of the Registrar
The Registrar checks:
• Whether the application is complete.
• Whether the union’s rules comply with the Act.
• Whether the minimum number of members have signed.
If everything is in order, the Registrar proceeds to register the union.
4. Certificate of Registration
Once the Registrar is satisfied, he/she enters the union’s details in the official register and
issues a Certificate of Registration.
• This certificate is proof that the union is legally recognized.
• From this point, the union becomes a legal entity—it can sue, be sued, own
property, and enjoy rights under the Act.
Diagram to Visualize
Here’s a simple flow diagram:
Workers form union (7+ members)
|
Application to Registrar
|
Check rules, documents, conditions
|
If satisfied → Register
|
Certificate of Registration issued
Why Registration Matters
• It gives unions legal protection.
• It allows them to negotiate with employers officially.
• It prevents fake or duplicate unions from misleading workers.
• It ensures transparency and accountability in union activities.
Conclusion
So, under the Trade Unions Act, 1926, registration is like giving a union its “birth certificate.”
Workers apply, the Registrar verifies, and once approved, a certificate is issued. This
Easy2Siksha.com
transforms the union from just a group of workers into a recognized legal body with rights
and responsibilities.
SECTION-B
3. What authories have been set up under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 for
invesgaon and selement of industrial disputes?
Ans: Introduction: Why are these authorities needed?
Imagine a factory where workers and management are not agreeing on wages, working
hours, or conditions. This disagreement is called an industrial dispute.
Now, if there is no proper system to solve such disputes, it can lead to strikes, lockouts, and
loss for both workers and employers.
To prevent this, the Government of India created the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, which
provides a structured mechanism (authorities) to investigate and settle disputes peacefully.
Types of Authorities under the Act
The Act has created two main types of authorities:
1. Preventive & Settlement Authorities (Non-Adjudicatory)
2. Adjudicatory Authorities (Decision-Making Bodies)
Let’s understand each one in a smooth flow.
1. Preventive & Settlement Authorities
These authorities try to prevent disputes or settle them through discussion, without giving
a formal judgment.
(1) Works Committee
A Works Committee is formed in industries where there are 100 or more workers.
Key Idea:
It is like a bridge between workers and management.
Easy2Siksha.com
Functions:
• Promote good relations between workers and employers
• Solve day-to-day minor issues
• Prevent disputes before they become serious
Think of it as a friendly discussion table inside the company.
(2) Conciliation Officer
A Conciliation Officer is appointed by the government.
Key Idea:
Acts as a mediator (middle person).
Functions:
• Talks to both parties (workers & employer)
• Tries to bring them to an agreement
• Sends a report to the government
If settlement happens → dispute ends
If not → case moves forward
Easy2Siksha.com
(3) Board of Conciliation
This is a group version of a Conciliation Officer.
Structure:
• Chairman (independent person)
• Representatives of workers and employers
Functions:
• Promote settlement through discussions
• Handle more complex disputes
Think of it as a team mediation panel.
(4) Court of Inquiry
Easy2Siksha.com
This authority is set up to investigate disputes deeply.
Key Idea:
It does fact-finding, not decision-making.
Functions:
• Investigate the dispute
• Find causes and facts
• Submit a report to the government
It does NOT give a final decision—only helps in understanding the issue.
2. Adjudicatory Authorities
If settlement fails, the dispute goes to these authorities. They give binding decisions.
(5) Labour Court
Key Idea:
Handles specific and less complex disputes.
Deals With:
• Dismissal or discharge of workers
• Legality of strikes/lockouts
Easy2Siksha.com
• Standing orders
It is like a special court for worker-related issues.
(6) Industrial Tribunal
Key Idea:
Deals with more complex and serious disputes.
Deals With:
• Wages
• Working conditions
• Bonus
• Allowances
Easy2Siksha.com
It has wider powers than Labour Court.
(7) National Tribunal
Key Idea:
Handles disputes of national importance.
When is it used?
• When dispute affects multiple states
• When issue is of national interest
Example: Dispute in a big company operating across India.
Simple Flow Diagram
Here’s a simple way to remember the process:
Industrial Dispute Arises
↓
Works Committee (internal discussion)
↓
Conciliation Officer / Board
↓
(If not solved)
↓
Court of Inquiry (fact finding)
↓
Labour Court / Tribunal
↓
National Tribunal (if national issue)
Easy Memory Trick
Remember this sequence:
“Work → Conciliate → Inquire → Judge”
• Work Committee
• Conciliation Officer / Board
• Court of Inquiry
• Labour Court / Tribunal
Easy2Siksha.com
Conclusion
The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 has created a well-organized system of authorities to
ensure that disputes between workers and employers are handled peacefully and fairly.
• First, it tries friendly settlement (Works Committee, Conciliation)
• Then, it moves to investigation (Court of Inquiry)
• Finally, it provides legal decisions (Labour Court, Tribunal)
This system helps:
• Maintain industrial peace
• Protect workers’ rights
• Ensure smooth functioning of industries
4. Enumerate the provision of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 relang to strikes and lock-
out.
Ans: First, What Are Strikes and Lock-outs?
• A strike is when workers collectively stop working to pressurize the employer for
better wages, working conditions, or rights.
• A lock-out is the opposite—when an employer shuts down the workplace to
pressurize workers or resist their demands.
Both are powerful tools, but they can disrupt industries and the economy. That’s why the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 lays down clear rules to regulate them.
Provisions of the Act Relating to Strikes and Lock-outs
1. Prior Notice Requirement
• In public utility services (like railways, electricity, water supply), workers cannot go
on strike without giving 14 days’ prior notice to the employer.
• Similarly, employers cannot declare a lock-out without giving 14 days’ notice.
• This ensures time for negotiation and avoids sudden disruption of essential services.
2. Prohibition During Conciliation or Adjudication
• Strikes and lock-outs are prohibited when:
o A conciliation proceeding is pending before a Conciliation Officer.
o A case is pending before a Labour Court, Industrial Tribunal, or National
Tribunal.
o During arbitration proceedings.
• The idea is simple: if a dispute is already being legally resolved, neither side should
escalate matters by stopping work or closing the workplace.
Easy2Siksha.com
3. Prohibition During Settlement Period
• If a settlement or award has been reached, strikes and lock-outs are prohibited
during the period it is in operation.
• This ensures stability and respect for agreements already made.
4. Illegal Strikes and Lock-outs
A strike or lock-out becomes illegal if:
• It is started without proper notice in public utility services.
• It is declared during conciliation, adjudication, or arbitration proceedings.
• It violates the conditions of a settlement or award.
Workers or employers engaging in illegal strikes or lock-outs can face penalties under the
Act.
5. Penalties
• Workers participating in illegal strikes may face fines or disciplinary action.
• Employers declaring illegal lock-outs may face fines and legal consequences.
• The Act aims to discourage irresponsible use of strikes and lock-outs.
6. Protection for Legal Strikes
If a strike is conducted legally:
• Workers cannot be penalized merely for participating.
• Employers must respect the workers’ right to strike, provided it follows the law.
This balances the rights of workers and employers.
Diagram to Visualize
Here’s a simple flow diagram:
STRIKES & LOCK-OUTS (Industrial Disputes Act, 1947)
---------------------------------------------------
|
-----------------------------------------------
| |
Strikes Lock-outs
| |
Notice (14 days in public utility) Notice (14 days in public utility)
| |
Prohibited during conciliation/adjudication Prohibited during
conciliation/adjudication
| |
Illegal if rules not followed Illegal if rules not followed
| |
Penalties imposed Penalties imposed
Easy2Siksha.com
Wrapping It Up
So, under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, strikes and lock-outs are not banned outright—
but they are regulated. Workers and employers must give notice, avoid action during legal
proceedings, and respect settlements. If they don’t, their actions become illegal and
punishable.
The Act tries to balance two sides: workers’ right to protest and employers’ right to protect
business, while ensuring that industries don’t collapse due to sudden stoppages.
SECTION-C
5. What are the dues of Employees' State Insurance Corporaon and Standing Commiee
?
Ans: Duties of Employees’ State Insurance Corporation and Standing Committee
To understand this topic easily, imagine a large system that takes care of workers when they
fall sick, get injured, or face any kind of employment-related risk. In India, this system is
managed by the Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC). It works under the
Employees’ State Insurance (ESI) Act and provides social security benefits to employees.
But ESIC alone does not do everything directly. It has a helping body called the Standing
Committee, which handles day-to-day operations.
1. Duties of Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC)
Think of ESIC as the main governing body or the “head office” that plans and controls the
entire system.
Main Duties of ESIC
1. Administration of the ESI Scheme
The primary duty of ESIC is to manage and run the ESI scheme across the country.
This includes:
• Providing medical benefits
• Giving financial support during sickness, maternity, or injury
In simple terms: ESIC ensures that workers get help when they need it.
Easy2Siksha.com
2. Framing Policies and Rules
ESIC creates important rules and policies regarding:
• Employee benefits
• Contribution rates (how much employees and employers pay)
• Eligibility conditions
It acts like a “rule-maker” for the entire system.
3. Managing Funds
ESIC collects money from:
• Employees
• Employers
It then uses this money to provide benefits.
Think of it like a financial manager that ensures money is properly used.
4. Setting Up Hospitals and Dispensaries
ESIC is responsible for:
• Establishing hospitals
• Running dispensaries
• Providing medical services
So, if an insured employee falls sick, ESIC ensures treatment is available.
5. Ensuring Benefits to Workers
ESIC provides various benefits like:
• Sickness benefit
• Maternity benefit
• Disablement benefit
• Dependents’ benefit
Its main goal is social security.
Easy2Siksha.com
6. Supervision and Control
ESIC supervises:
• Regional offices
• Local offices
• Implementation of schemes
It ensures everything runs smoothly across India.
7. Appointment of Staff
ESIC appoints:
• Medical staff
• Administrative staff
It builds the team that runs the system.
8. Budget and Accounts Management
It prepares:
• Budget plans
• Financial reports
Ensures transparency and proper use of funds.
2. Duties of Standing Committee
Now imagine ESIC as the “brain” and the Standing Committee as the “hands” that actually
do the daily work.
The Standing Committee is responsible for executing the decisions of ESIC.
Main Duties of Standing Committee
1. Day-to-Day Administration
The Standing Committee handles:
Easy2Siksha.com
• Daily operations
• Routine decisions
It ensures the system keeps running without delay.
2. Implementation of ESIC Policies
Whatever rules ESIC makes, the Standing Committee:
• Applies them in real life
• Ensures proper execution
It converts plans into action.
3. Management of ESI Funds
The committee:
• Oversees spending
• Ensures proper financial use
Works like a finance operator under ESIC.
4. Supervision of Local Offices
It monitors:
• Regional offices
• Local ESI offices
Makes sure services reach employees properly.
5. Handling Claims and Benefits
The committee ensures:
• Employees receive benefits on time
• Claims are processed efficiently
Helps workers get support quickly.
Easy2Siksha.com
6. Maintenance of Records
It keeps proper records of:
• Contributions
• Benefits paid
• Employees covered
Ensures accountability.
7. Reporting to ESIC
The Standing Committee reports:
• Progress
• Problems
• Performance
Keeps ESIC informed about ground reality.
Simple Diagram to Understand
Here is a very easy diagram to visualize the relationship:
Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC)
│
(Policy Making, Control, Supervision, Finance)
│
▼
Standing Committee
(Execution, Daily Operations)
│
▼
Local Offices / Hospitals
│
▼
Employees
In short:
• ESIC = Planning + Control
• Standing Committee = Implementation + Execution
Easy2Siksha.com
Easy Comparison Table
Feature
ESIC
Standing Committee
Role
Main authority
Executive body
Function
Policy making
Implementation
Focus
Big decisions
Daily operations
Control
Overall system
Local execution
Nature
Strategic
Practical
Conclusion
To sum it up in a very simple way:
The Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) is like the head office that designs
policies, manages funds, and supervises the entire system. It ensures that workers receive
social security and medical benefits.
On the other hand, the Standing Committee acts like the working team that carries out
these plans in real life. It handles daily administration, manages funds practically, and
ensures that benefits reach employees on time.
6. What are the dierent types of benets provided by the Employees State Insurance Act,
1948?
Ans: First, What is the ESI Act?
The Employees’ State Insurance Act, 1948 was created to provide social security to
workers. It’s like a safety net: when employees face sickness, accidents, or other hardships,
the Act ensures they and their families get support.
The benefits under this Act are funded by contributions from both employers and
employees, and they are managed by the Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC).
Types of Benefits under the ESI Act
The Act provides six major types of benefits. Let’s walk through them like a story.
1. Medical Benefit
• Covers full medical care for insured persons and their families.
• Includes doctor consultations, medicines, hospitalization, and specialist services.
• Provided through ESIC hospitals, dispensaries, and approved medical institutions.
Easy2Siksha.com
Example: If a worker falls ill, they can get free treatment without worrying about
hospital bills.
2. Sickness Benefit
• Cash compensation is given when an employee cannot work due to illness.
• Usually, 70% of wages are paid for up to 91 days in a year.
• Requires medical certification.
Example: If a worker has dengue and needs rest, they still receive part of their salary
during recovery.
3. Maternity Benefit
• Paid to insured women during pregnancy, confinement, or miscarriage.
• Covers leave for 26 weeks (extendable in certain cases).
• Also includes medical care related to childbirth.
Example: A female worker gets paid leave and medical care during pregnancy, ensuring
financial stability.
4. Disablement Benefit
• If a worker suffers an injury at work, they receive compensation.
• Temporary disablement: Cash benefit until recovery.
• Permanent disablement: Lifelong pension depending on the extent of disability.
Example: If a worker loses partial eyesight in an accident, they receive financial support
for life.
5. Dependants’ Benefit
• If a worker dies due to an employment-related injury, their dependants (spouse,
children, parents) receive monthly payments.
• This ensures the family is financially supported even after the breadwinner is gone.
Example: If a factory worker dies in an accident, his widow and children receive regular
financial assistance.
6. Funeral Benefit
• A lump sum amount is given to the family to cover funeral expenses of the deceased
insured person.
• Currently, this benefit is around ₹15,000 (subject to government updates).
Example: If a worker passes away, the family gets financial help to conduct the funeral
with dignity.
Easy2Siksha.com
Diagram to Visualize
Here’s a simple diagram showing the benefits:
BENEFITS UNDER ESI ACT, 1948
----------------------------
|
-----------------------------------------------
| | | | | |
Medical Sickness Maternity Disablement Dependants Funeral
Benefit Benefit Benefit Benefit Benefit Benefit
Conclusion
So, the ESI Act, 1948 is like a shield for workers. It protects them against sickness, accidents,
maternity needs, disability, and even supports their families after death. The six benefits—
medical, sickness, maternity, disablement, dependants, and funeral—ensure that workers
are not left helpless in times of crisis.
SECTION-D
7. Explain when an employer is liable to pay compensaon to an employee injured by
accident 'arising out of and in the course of employment'?
Ans: Introduction
Imagine a worker named Ravi. He works in a factory. One day, while operating a machine,
his hand gets injured. Now the question arises:
Is the employer responsible to pay compensation?
The answer depends on one key legal condition:
The injury must be caused by an accident “arising out of and in the course of employment.”
This principle comes from the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923.
Let’s break this down step by step in a very simple way.
Two Important Conditions
For an employer to be liable (responsible), both conditions must be satisfied:
Easy2Siksha.com
1. In the Course of Employment
This means:
The accident must happen during working time, at the workplace, or while doing job-
related duties.
Example:
• Ravi is working on a machine → injury happens → ✔ covered
• Ravi is going to the washroom during work → slips → ✔ covered
So, anything happening while you are doing your job or something related to it is
included.
2. Arising Out of Employment
This means:
The accident must be connected to the nature of the job or risk involved in the job.
Example:
• Machine injury in factory → ✔ job-related risk
• Electric shock while repairing wires → ✔ job-related
But:
• Personal fight with colleague → not related to job
• Injury due to personal illness → not covered
Simple Diagram for Better Understanding
EMPLOYER LIABLE
│
┌─────────────┴─────────────┐
│ │
In the Course of Employment Arising Out of Employment
(Time/Place of Work) (Connection with Job Risk)
│ │
└─────────────┬─────────────┘
│
Compensation Payable
If both sides are true, then the employer must pay compensation.
Easy2Siksha.com
Detailed Explanation with Examples
Case 1: Clearly Covered
Ravi is working in a factory. His hand gets injured by a machine.
✔ Happened during work
✔ Caused by job-related risk
Employer must pay compensation
Case 2: Covered (Indirect Work)
Ravi is sent by his boss to deliver goods. On the way, he meets with an accident.
✔ He was on duty
✔ Work-related activity
Employer is liable
Case 3: Not Covered
Ravi fights with another worker due to a personal issue and gets injured.
✔ Happened at workplace
Not related to job
Employer not liable
Case 4: Personal Negligence
Ravi ignores safety rules and gets injured.
In some cases, compensation may be reduced or denied if:
• He was drunk
• He deliberately ignored safety
Easy2Siksha.com
Important Legal Points
Let’s understand a few important rules in simple words:
1. Accident Must Be Sudden
The injury should be caused by a sudden event.
Example:
• Machine accident → ✔
• Slowly developing disease → sometimes covered (if job-related)
2. Occupational Diseases
Some diseases are also covered if caused by job.
Example:
• Lung disease in mining workers
• Skin disease in chemical workers
These are treated as accidents under law.
3. Notional Extension Theory
This is very interesting
Employment is not always limited to factory walls.
Example:
• Injury while entering factory gate
• Accident while leaving workplace
Still covered because job “extends” beyond strict working hours.
4. Employer’s Responsibility
Employer must pay compensation when:
Easy2Siksha.com
• Injury causes disability
• Worker dies
• Worker loses earning capacity
Easy Way to Remember
Just remember this simple formula:
TIME + PLACE + JOB CONNECTION = COMPENSATION
If all three match → employer is liable
Real-Life Understanding
Think of it like this:
When you are working, your employer is responsible for your safety only when you are
doing work-related things.
If something goes wrong because of your job → employer pays
If something goes wrong because of personal reasons → employer does not pay
Conclusion
To sum it up in simple words:
An employer is liable to pay compensation only when:
✔ The accident happens during employment (time/place)
✔ The accident is connected to the job (risk/work nature)
Both conditions must be fulfilled together.
This rule ensures fairness:
• It protects workers from job-related risks
• It prevents misuse where injury is unrelated to work
Easy2Siksha.com
8. State the rules regarding distribuon of compensaon under the Workmen's
Compensaon Act, 1923?
Ans: First, What is the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923?
This Act was designed to protect workers who suffer injuries or death while performing their
duties. It ensures that employees (or their dependants) receive financial compensation
from employers in case of accidents, occupational diseases, or death arising out of
employment.
But here’s the key: the Act doesn’t just say “pay compensation.” It lays down rules for how
compensation should be distributed so that it reaches the right people fairly and securely.
Rules Regarding Distribution of Compensation
1. Payment to Workman
• If the injured worker survives, the compensation is paid directly to them.
• The amount depends on the nature of injury—temporary, permanent, partial, or
total disablement.
• The Commissioner ensures the money is paid promptly and in full.
2. Payment to Dependants (in case of death)
• If the worker dies due to an accident at work, compensation is paid to their
dependants.
• Dependants include spouse, children, parents, and other family members who relied
on the worker’s income.
• The employer cannot directly hand over the money to the family; instead, it must be
deposited with the Commissioner for Workmen’s Compensation.
• The Commissioner then distributes the amount among dependants according to
their needs and legal rights.
3. Deposit with Commissioner
• In cases of death or permanent disablement, the employer must deposit the
compensation with the Commissioner rather than paying it directly.
• This ensures transparency and prevents misuse.
• The Commissioner investigates who the rightful dependants are and how much each
should receive.
4. Apportionment of Compensation
• The Commissioner decides how to divide the compensation among dependants.
• For example:
o A widow may receive a larger share.
o Minor children may get money kept in a trust until they reach adulthood.
Easy2Siksha.com
o Parents may receive a portion if they were financially dependent on the
worker.
This prevents disputes and ensures fair distribution.
5. Method of Payment
• Compensation can be paid as a lump sum or in installments.
• For minors or dependants who cannot manage money, the Commissioner may order
the amount to be deposited in a bank or invested safely.
• This protects vulnerable dependants from exploitation.
6. No Direct Settlement Allowed
• Employers are not allowed to settle compensation privately with dependants.
• Any agreement must go through the Commissioner to ensure legality and fairness.
• This prevents employers from underpaying or pressuring families into unfair deals.
7. Distribution in Case of Dispute
• If there is a dispute about who qualifies as a dependant, the Commissioner
investigates and decides.
• For example, if both parents and a widow claim compensation, the Commissioner
examines evidence of dependency before dividing the amount.
8. Interest and Penalty
• If the employer delays depositing compensation, they may have to pay interest and
sometimes a penalty.
• This ensures employers act quickly and responsibly.
Diagram to Visualize
Here’s a simple diagram showing the flow:
Worker injured/dead at work
|
Employer liable to pay
|
---------------------------------
| |
Worker survives Worker dies
| |
Paid directly to worker Employer deposits with Commissioner
|
Commissioner investigates dependants
|
Fair distribution among widow, children,
parents
Easy2Siksha.com
Conclusion
So, the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923 doesn’t just say “give money.” It sets rules for
distribution to make sure compensation reaches the right hands:
• Direct payment to the worker if alive.
• Deposit with Commissioner in case of death or permanent disablement.
• Fair apportionment among dependants.
• Protection for minors and vulnerable family members.
• No private settlements allowed.
The story is simple: the Act acts like a guardian, ensuring that compensation is not misused
and that families of workers are supported fairly and legally.
“This paper has been carefully prepared for educaonal purposes. If you noce any
mistakes or have suggesons, feel free to share your feedback.”
